What is it about Columbo that makes him so likeable?
That’s just one of the questions answered in this episode, as Jade (who admits she’s no expert) brings us the very first episode, in all its 70s glory. We dissect how sometimes knowing who the killer is from the beginning can be a welcome change in cosy crime, the episode's very well-known director and why 'charming' in the 70s left us with our skin crawling today.
Subscribe to Cosy Crime Time wherever you get your podcasts and don’t forget to leave us a review - it really helps!
You can follow us too (but not in a stalker way).
Instagram @cosy.crimetime
TikTok @cosycrimetime
YouTube Cosy Crime Time
Until next time, stay cosy and don’t commit crimes!
Give £5, £10 or £20 now and help CALM in their fight against suicide: https://www.justgiving.com/page/podomedy-stay-tuned
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
[00:00:00] There have been 69 episodes in total, so there's a lot of episodes out there. Yeah. Nice. I like that they finished on 69. And they're long as well. Welcome to Cosy Crime Time with Becca Bain and Jade Gebbie, where we talk about a different Cosy Crime series each episode. Is there a murder everywhere our main character appears? But they're not under suspicion from the police in any way. In fact, they're working with the authorities?
[00:00:27] Then that sounds like our kind of show. We'll be revealing killers and giving away twists so we have a blanket spoiler warning as well as a cosy blanket to wrap ourselves up in. Hi Jade, how are you? I'm alright, thank you.
[00:00:56] What is your cosy thing that's happened to you this week? My cosy thing? I guess it's the necessity of being cosy is my cosy thing this week. I remember we were talking in a previous episode about how we couldn't wait to get cosy and now that time is here. Yes. There is currently a blanket around my legs. Nice.
[00:01:20] I feel like I'm going to need to dig out my fluffy slipper boots and I'm really having trouble getting out of bed in the morning because it's cold outside of the bed and inside is nice and cosy. Yesterday I didn't get out of bed until like after midday. That is so bad. It's not too bad because it was a Sunday yesterday so it was fine. That's what Sundays are for. Jade, yesterday was a Monday. Oh yeah. Whoops.
[00:01:50] I forgot that. I know your work schedule is slightly different but oh my god. I forgot. No, yesterday was a Monday and I could not get out of bed because I was too cosy. So I'm not going as swinging as far as to say that it's actually a burden how cosy I am. It's still really nice. I'm just saying it's getting in the way of my productivity. Yeah, definitely. I take that back now but I remember it was Monday. But what about you?
[00:02:19] Have you had any crimes happening to you this week? I would say just a general crime. So we're recording this at the beginning of November. It's the sort of second week of November now and I would say general crime is that there's Christmas adverts on already. Like that's a crime surely. Like I do like Christmas but I would still say early first week of November is basically
[00:02:47] as soon as Halloween finished it was Christmas adverts. Yeah, it's insane and you can predict that now that as soon as Halloween is over it is Christmas advert time and it doesn't make it any less annoying. It's become a topic of conversation amongst friends and family as to whether the M&S James
[00:03:15] Norton Christmas advert is horrific or hilarious. Yeah, I can't decide. He definitely doesn't seem like Santa Claus to me. I mean... No. Sexy Santa Claus. Oh no, the consensus is no one thinks it's good. Is it horrific or hilarious? I think it might be a bit of both to be fair. I think so too. It's too soon. Yeah, exactly. That's what I was thinking.
[00:03:44] I don't want to come across as a Scrooge but I would say it's a bit soon. I would say that is my crime this week. I am fully on board with you considering that a crime, Jade. I really am. So, on to the episode. This is my episode this week that I am leading. Yeah. And I am extremely excited because we're going to be talking about a show that I really love. Now, up top, I will admit for listeners and for you, Becca, that I wouldn't call myself an expert on this.
[00:04:12] I haven't seen that many episodes. But what I've seen, I've loved. And I've been wanting to talk about this show for a while because it's a little bit different to everything else that we've covered. So, we're going to be covering the brilliant, the iconic Columbo. Columbo. Have you? I mean, obviously now you've seen as our requisite for this show, you've seen the first episode. But had you seen any Columbo before? I've never seen it.
[00:04:42] Never seen it. I'm very familiar with the concept of Columbo. But the closest I'd come to seeing it was in Peep Show when Mark Corrigan goes, do a Columbo, do a Columbo. And that just reminded me. And yeah, the good old Columbo. Only one technique, of course, but still. Yeah, so that is my entire frame of reference for Columbo.
[00:05:10] And having watched the first episode, it's not inaccurate. It's a very good summary of what he does. But no, no frame of reference for Columbo before this. I think that Columbo is, well, for anyone that doesn't know that's listening, it is an American show. It was broadcast on NBC and then it moved to ABC. And it ran, it had two pilots in 1968, 1971.
[00:05:38] But then it officially ran from 1971 to 2003. Although between 1990 and 2003, it was quite infrequent. But it's, so it's an American show. And I believe the impression I get is that like in America, it's kind of like our Midsummer, like it's on all the time. And like everyone's seen at least an episode. And it's like a big, really big show in America.
[00:06:05] Here, maybe before our time, it was on a bit. But it's not one that's like, you know, regularly. Like Murder, She Wrote, that I remember being on a lot, even over here. I don't remember Columbo being on when I was young or like ITV3 or anything like that. No. As I've said before on this show, my mum is my main frame of reference for Cozy Crimes that came out before I was born or when I was quite young.
[00:06:33] So if my mum wasn't watching it, I didn't know it existed. And my mum, as far as I'm aware, has never seen Columbo. No. So yeah, I think you're right. I don't think it made its way over the pond in quite the same way as some of the others. Like Diagnosis Murder, for example, that came through. Yeah. And yeah, the iconic murder, She Wrote. Yeah, exactly. That's the thing. And I actually, so in the lockdown, I was living back with my parents. And obviously there was time to watch everything.
[00:07:02] And me and my dad watched some episodes of this in the lockdown. So that's kind of where I started seeing it. But like I say, I haven't seen like loads of it, but there have been 69 episodes in total. So there's a lot of episodes out there. Yeah. Nice. I like that they finished on 69. And they're long as well. Like this one was an hour and 15.
[00:07:31] And so I guess an hour and a half with ads. I've got more to watch. So I just want to point out for anyone listening who might be like a Columbo expert. I'm not pretending to be an expert, but I do love it. And we'd love to hear from actual Columbo experts. And maybe later down the line when you have finished it, we'll do part two. Yes, exactly. And because there's so many, obviously with like when we did Poirot, we spoke more about the specific episode.
[00:07:59] And we've kind of spoke that when we do get around to doing things like Midsummer Murders and Jonathan Creek will likely do the same because there's so many episodes and there's so much to get through. So with this, we will I will tell you a few facts and things that I found out. But generally, we'll be talking about the episode that we watched to let everyone know. And for yourself, Becca, the synopsis of Columbo generally. And then I'll tell you the synopsis of the episode and the episode we're going to talk about. But he's an L.A. homicide detective.
[00:08:29] Lieutenant Columbo uses his humble ways and ingenious demeanor to root out even the most well concealed crime. So that's the summary of the show generally. Now, we're going to be talking about murder by the book. So this is series one, episode one. There had previously been two pilots and also a play. But this episode was released in April 18th, 1972.
[00:08:55] And the summary is when one member of a mystery writing team decides to take a break from his less talented partner and go solo, he becomes a victim of a real life murder mystery. And the big thing about this episode, while there were no sort of big names that at least I knew about, I'm sure a lot of people in it had been like gone on to do loads on American TV.
[00:09:20] But they're not people that have, again, crossed the pond, apart from Peter Falk, who plays Columbo. This episode was directed by a young, only 24 year old, Steven Spielberg. What? Yeah, and this is four years before he directed Jaws. Oh, wow. Oh, that's an impressive get. Do you know what?
[00:09:44] We don't need to know any of the cast went on to bigger and better things if we know that the director. That's mad. Yeah. And only being 24 as well. Like, imagine. It's a baby. Oh, wow. Yeah, so that was really cool. And I mean, there are some really good crossfades in this, like very 70s style, where they're like driving along and then you see the trees from a previous shot kind of like fade away.
[00:10:12] Yes, very, very 70s. Everything about it is very American 70s. This episode. Right down to like, what's considered charming. Oh, yeah. Oh, my God. Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah, what was considered charming in the 70s is absolutely skin crawling. Oh, my God. If you watch it for the first time today. Yeah.
[00:10:41] Honestly, without jumping ahead too much, I think the way he, the way he speaks to women, if he'd spoken to me like that, I would have just immediately gone. You've merged someone. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, definitely. You are not right. Right. Yes. So actually, before we get in the episode, one thing that you've kind of alluded to there, actually, is a good point, is so Becca there was talking about one of the characters. And it's not a spoiler because right at the start, we actually know who done it.
[00:11:11] So this isn't a who done it. This is what they call a how they catch them. It's not the catch. Yes. But this is how they catch them. So we as the audience know who actually did it. And it's all about watching Columbo figure it out. And this is the same format that, well, this format inspired a show that I really love that at some point we'll talk about. But Poker Face, have you heard Poker Face?
[00:11:37] I haven't seen it, but you have spoken about it and have recommended it to me before. So this is the same format where like the first 15 minutes, like with this, we don't even see Columbo for like the first 15, 20 minutes. And then we see the murder take place and then Columbo comes into it and he's figuring out. But we know the whole time who who done it. So it's kind of a different format.
[00:12:00] And I'm pretty sure that Columbo kind of was the show that kind of, I'm sure other things had maybe done it a little bit, but this was like the first main thing that that used this idea. So, yeah. So I thought that was quite interesting. And that's kind of another reason why I wanted to cover it to be something a little different. Yeah, it really took me by surprise. Oh, I didn't realise you. Because I know nothing. I know nothing about it.
[00:12:29] So I was expecting some sort of subversion at the beginning of he's setting up all this stuff and then an unknown person was going to kill him. It's not a commonly used thing with cozy crime. The cozy crime is who done it. Yeah. Yeah. And so that was, that was really interesting.
[00:12:54] I was still expecting an unknown killer and we would have to figure out who it was. Yeah. So as soon as it, as soon as the murder happens, I was like, oh, this is going to be different. Yeah. Yeah. Definitely. Well, that's why I kind of wanted to talk about it. And yeah, you're right. I don't think I've ever seen it in a British show. Like if we know who the killer is in a British show, it's like a drama or it's like, yeah, it's, you know, it's grittier. Yeah. Yeah. It's, yeah, definitely.
[00:13:23] And the suspense comes in of how are they going to figure out that it's them? Yeah. How are they going to catch them? As you say, whereas cozy crime doesn't normally deal in a great amount of suspense, I would say. Yeah. It's because surely suspense is the antithesis of being cozy. Yeah. Yeah. Um, but Columbo manages to do both, I would say. Yes, definitely.
[00:13:49] So actually, so I keep not talking about the episode specifically, but I really, really want to know what you thought of Columbo as a character. Love him. Yeah. Love him. He's so funny. He's so cute. Love, love him. Short king. Columbo is a short king. You immediately, you immediately love him. Yeah. He's so likeable. He's so affable.
[00:14:14] And yeah, he just, he sees people and we see two sides of that within about the first 20 minutes of meeting him, maybe even less of he sees what the, the murdered man's wife needs. And yes, it is, it is employed to, to help with the investigation, but in the way that he does it, it's still very considerate. Yes. And he puts her at ease.
[00:14:43] And when he's like fumbling around her kitchen making an omelet, he's adorable. He's so sweet. So there's two creators I have written their name down, William Link and Richard Levinson. And they said that he was partially inspired by Portree Petschovich from Crime and Punishment and also of Father Brown, which I didn't realise this at all. I thought it was just a TV show, but that's an old book. So I didn't realise that. Interesting.
[00:15:12] Because I was like, what are they talking about Father Brown? But I... Must be a different Father Brown. I personally see a lot of flashes of Poirot in him and also Miss Marple. That's interesting. Because I think what he does is he acts throughout this, like he, to kind of disarm who he thinks is the suspect, who eventually is the killer, who we know, but he's trying to figure it out.
[00:15:41] He sort of disarms him by acting bumbling. And then he'll go, hang on, one thing I didn't quite realise is... Or he'll say things like, people are different because I myself wouldn't take a plane and stuff like that. And it's like the way he disarms people. And it's kind of like Miss Marple where people just think, oh, she's a little old lady. What's she going to know? And also kind of with Poirot where they're like, oh, he's an older man. And a lot of the time, because of the time of the books, they're like, oh, he's not from Britain.
[00:16:10] So he doesn't understand, which obviously is ridiculous. But, you know. But still believed. Yeah, I think it's a very cosy crime thing of being underestimated, being turned to the, whoever is doing the detection, whether amateur or professional, being turned to their advantage. I think this is the most, and I don't mean blatant in a bad way.
[00:16:35] I mean, this is a staple of showing how an underestimated detective can use that to their advantage. And it was the moment that he, because there's a couple of little moments where he does the, oh, just one more thing. Yeah. After luring him in, the killer in, and making him talk too much and be a bit too assertive in what he believes.
[00:17:05] And too arrogant. Oh, God, yeah. Because he's a, yeah. As a co-writer of a crime series, wanting to plan the perfect crime and thinking you've got away with it, and just his personality anyway. He is so arrogant. He's so arrogant. And so watching him get trapped into talking too much or saying a bit more than he'd maybe originally planned. Yeah.
[00:17:31] And then just going, huh, why did you open your post after you found his body? I think it was the one after that where I like, I was like, oh, he's got him. Yeah. Yeah. He's got him. Um, and I was, I was so on board more than I was expecting to be, but you do, you, you want Columbo to win. And that's the, that's the genius of the, that the premise switch of we know who it is.
[00:18:01] Because I think if you, if it was the murder mystery, we wouldn't be as on board in a way. I don't know. Yeah, definitely. So yeah, what I'll do is I'll just go through a couple of points to bring the listen up to speed. So, um, sorry, I think I've jumped ahead quite a lot because I'm so enthusiastic about this series. I mean, that was me asking what you thought about Columbo and there's no way for you to speak about Columbo without speaking about some of the things he says and does in this episode. Basically.
[00:18:29] Uh, I mean, we talked about how seventies this is, but the opening credits, I just have to say are so, so seventies. And we have one man, uh, who we later find out is called Jim and he's in his office tip tapping away on his typewriter. And it did get me thinking of, um, obviously we're both writers. We never worked in a typewriter era. There've been times when I've considered getting a typewriter because it means I wouldn't be distracted by the internet when I'm trying to write.
[00:18:58] Oh, very analog. I like it. But I do wonder if it would get quite annoying because that tip tapping, I was like, how is he concentrating? Same. I wonder if it, it must've become white noise. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. At a certain, at a certain point. And I completely agree. I thought the exact same thing. And then I thought, well, if women in a typing pool can do it, where there's like, there's like 10, 15, 20 of them all at the same time, if they can do it and block it out, this one
[00:19:27] guy could manage. Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. Um, and yeah, so another car kind of turns, turns up and so a car turns up at the office and hands gets a gun out of a glove compartment and there's no theme music. There's just the typewriter sounds carrying on, which is quite good. But the guy who arrives in the office with the gun is Ken and they're a double act writing team, Ken and Jim.
[00:19:55] They're mystery writers having written a detective series with a detective called Mrs. Melville and it's very Agatha Christie coded, I thought. Very Marple coded. Yeah. Um, and basically what it turns out is even though they've had a very successful partnership, um, Jim, who is typing away, wants to go off on his own and they've clearly had an argument,
[00:20:20] but Ken is there to, uh, patch things up, patch things up. I'm using air quotes and he wants to patch things up, but he says that friendship is more important than partnership. And Ken persuades Jim after a lot of persuading to go to his new cabin. Um, and he pretends he left a lighter in the office. So he goes back and Ken, uh, like trestages the office and he, um, like knocks things over and stuff.
[00:20:49] And then he takes, uh, Jim to his cabin. And Ken is who you were talking about, about being a very unlikable character. I mean, he was so right from the start, he was so unlikable. He is smarm personified. I don't, I cannot remember the last time I saw such a smarmy character. And I think it helps to know that he is the killer because you want to see him get brought down.
[00:21:18] Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. It's, um, yeah, it's an interesting thing I did when I was reading about like facts and things. Another thing, I can't remember the exact wording they use, but another thing that the, uh, creators said is that it was like an important kind of trope of their villains to always be a bit like, uh, like have the upper hand be maybe a bit like snooty or a bit arrogant. And I think it's probably if we watch more episodes and I'm pretty sure from the other
[00:21:47] episodes that I've seen that it's kind of, the characters aren't all the set, like the villains aren't always the same, but they've got that trait to them. And I suppose it's that thing of, uh, them wanting to see their downfall. Definitely. Definitely. I, it's, yeah, I can imagine it wouldn't be as satisfying or maybe it would, I don't know. Would it be as satisfying if it was a, a desperate person who did it in a, an act of passion or
[00:22:16] like in the heat of the moment, would that be as satisfying? So, uh, we see that, um, on the way down to the cabin, Ken stops at a shop, the local store and he leaves the woman who later on we find out her name is Lily. Uh, he leaves the woman in the shop who clearly fancies him, um, a signed book. And she makes it clear that he's a bit of a lothario because she's like, oh, which woman
[00:22:46] are you with? But he says that he's alone all week. And while he's in there, he calls Jim's wife to tell her that they've patched things up and he is already in his cabin. Hmm. Setting up the alibi. Exactly. Yeah. And at the time I was like, what's he doing? But then it, like it became, um, well just in terms of, I mean, I knew he was trying to set up the alibi, but I was like, why is he calling from the shop?
[00:23:15] And I was a bit confused. And then obviously in a bit, he makes Jim call his wife from the cabin, but saying he's in the office. But then what I, the clever thing with this killer is that when Columbo checks the records, he says, oh, you made a call from the cabin, which was Jim calling the wife, but he can then say, oh, that was me calling the, that was me calling his wife.
[00:23:45] And I've said that in the most confusing way, but it was clever basically. Yeah, it was. And if he hadn't been so arrogant about it, I might have given him more, more that was like, more that was due to him. Cause it is, it's, it's the moment he leaves the lighter behind to give him an excuse to go back and trash the office. He knows he's meticulously planned this. But Columbo's cleverer. Yes.
[00:24:13] And there are some elements that he does not account for. They get to the cabin and it is in at this point where, when Jim is on the phone to his wife, pretending he's in the office, Ken kills Jim and shoots him. And so she hears him on the phone, but the wife thinks that he's in the office. So all the police and everyone descend on his office. And then this is where Columbo appears on the scene.
[00:24:44] Columbo is funny. We've already talked about him cooking an omelette, apparently. So, so basically Columbo meets the dead man's wife, takes her home, tries to find more stuff out, but also to look after her. And yeah, apparently when they were doing this scene, Columbo says, I'll tell you what the secret to a good omelette is. No eggs, just milk. Which I thought was a really funny line.
[00:25:11] And the woman at the time laughs in, she laughs at him. And then apparently the actual line was, the secret is just eggs, no milk, but Peter Ford got it wrong. And obviously they thought, oh, that's funny and kept it in. Because I thought it was a really funny line. That is great. And it really adds to the charm of him. Yeah. And like the bumbling nature. Yeah. That's so cute.
[00:25:36] He's just, it's the strangest thing of, he is just adorable. Yeah. Like, and like, would I describe him as such if he wasn't a short king? Probably not. So I need to check myself there. He's very, very personable. Yeah. And yeah, you just, you are immediately on board with him. He's very charming. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. Not in a bad way.
[00:26:01] That's true because, I mean, we've already talked about with this, with Ken, who is the killer, how he's supposed to be this Lothario. And I mean, so many of my notes are just like how weird and creepy he is. But he's obviously also supposed to be, in inverted commas, charming. Charming. Because he always has a new lady by his side. And the woman in the shop loves him. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:26:27] But like you said before, I cannot see it. I, oh God. It's, I don't know if this is too far on the actor, but I actually wrote in my notes, this is Savile coded. Just that, like, he's escorting the journalist out with his arm around her waist and like saying, I'll give you a more in-depth interview. Yeah. Yeah. It's so grim. It's, yeah.
[00:26:57] And it's, but you know what? It works so well. So obviously it turns out later that Lily, the shopkeeper, saw the writing partner that's been murdered in the car. So knows that Ken has been lying. And that dynamic. Yeah. I couldn't look away. Yeah. It was like a car crash. I couldn't look away because she fancies him and she desperately wants to sleep with
[00:27:27] him, I think. But she's also gonna blackmail him. Yeah. It is a really weird and well done dynamic. So well done of like, I, I want this to be, I want this to be a friendly blackmailing. I don't want it to, um, I don't want it to kind of ruin the flirty dynamic that we've built up over however long. And he clearly hates her and has always hated her. Yeah.
[00:27:55] He's like tolerated her at best, but now, but he's got to keep her on side. Yeah. Yeah. So he's really laying it on thick with the charm, which makes it even grosser because we know he's gonna kill her. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. And he gets the money out that she's asking for and gives it to her. We know she's gonna die. Yeah. They make us sit in that though.
[00:28:21] They make us sit in this really uncomfortable dynamic for quite a long time. Yeah. And I think it's so well done. It's so good. Yeah, definitely. Because I think that, um, we're, we're not really sure how he's gonna do it. And he suggests going out for a romantic, uh, swim at like going out on a boat because they live near a lake and to go out on a boat.
[00:28:45] And then she's like, oh, I trust you, but I don't trust you. And you could kill me basically. And then he ends up just smashing her over the head with a champagne bottle and dropping her body into the water. But it's weird as well because you would think that like their dynamic going back to that of like how much she is in awe of him. And even though she wants to, uh, blackmail him, you would think that a blackmailer would
[00:29:13] have the upper hand, but he still has the upper hand because she's so in love with him. And just, I mean, even from the beginning, from when they stop in the shop, he clearly like just finds her disgusting and hates her. People can correct me in the comments, but I wonder if maybe women, we might pick up more that he hated her right from the beginning. I mean, it's obvious towards the end, but because he doesn't fancy her. And so he doesn't see any like, maybe he doesn't even hate her.
[00:29:43] Maybe it's, he sees zero worth in her and he finds her gross because she fancies him, but he's not attracted to her because she's not, I mean, clearly a lot of the women he's dating are like a lot younger than him. And, um, and because she's so in awe of him, he just finds her so disgusting. And so it's weird because like, it's a weird dynamic, but it's so well done where she should have the upper hand over him, but she doesn't. Yeah.
[00:30:13] It's so good. I, yeah, I don't think that's a dynamic I've properly seen before. And as I say, the way it's so uncomfortable. Yeah. And I think it's the way that she kind of dies and her body's disposed of as well is something I was going to put to you, Jade of my hot take might be that Columbo himself is very, very cozy.
[00:30:43] Cozy. But the series isn't cozy crime. We see murders in cozy crimes. And like, I don't think it's any more maybe, maybe actually, maybe in terms of the way it's like shot, especially this episode, obviously we, we don't know necessarily as it goes on, though I would imagine it's fairly similar in terms of like tonally.
[00:31:08] And yeah, maybe you're right in terms of like disposing of the body at night and the way actually, okay, maybe you're right because there was a bit towards the end when I thought that the music was quite like a seventies horror film, but like not like a really terrifying one, but one that's like maybe a thriller. Like some of the music was a bit horror filmy, like a real seventies, that kind of plinky kind
[00:31:38] of sharp. Yes. So yeah, maybe tonally the way it's shot, the music that they've picked, the lighting, that's not that cozy. And I do think actually, maybe you've persuaded me. I was going to fight my corner. And as I was talking. No, I want you, I want you to, but I, yeah, I think, I mean, we've talked about it before. For example, with, you know, like Morse and things like that of even within cozy crime,
[00:32:08] it is a spectrum. Yeah. I mean, I would say this is a lot cozier than Morse. I've yeah. Morse definitely. I think. I think. He's on the line, if not slightly over the line in terms of cozy and not cozy. I completely agree. It was definitely worth exploring more. Yeah. And I'm glad we did him. We did his episodes. Yeah. Yeah. We did Morse. We did Morse. We did Morse.
[00:32:36] We endeavoured to do Morse. Very good. But I'm more of a Lewis girl myself, but. But yeah, but we could still see a lot of the kind of tropes and things used in a cozy crime employed early. Whereas I think, yeah, with with Columbo.
[00:33:02] And I wonder, does it feel a bit cozier because of the 70s kind of like film over it? You know, the the nostalgia aspect to it might make it more cozy. I don't know. That's a different question. But Columbo is definitely up there with one of the coziest professional detectives. I think I've seen. Yeah, I definitely think it's I wouldn't say the show is like fully like the coziest cozy crime ever.
[00:33:30] No, but it's I do still think that it's a cozy crime for sure. Yeah, definitely. And partly because Columbo brings out. But yeah, maybe totally the way it's shot and things. I do want to go back because we've jumped ahead a little. Sorry. And we haven't mentioned that Columbo finds out from the dead man's wife that he, Jim, the guy who was killed, was basically the brains of the operation.
[00:33:57] He was the one doing all the writing and Ken liked the fame, which actually worked out all right, really, for the majority of the time. Because I don't think from the sounds of it, Jim was that bothered about like going on chat shows and stuff. So Ken did the promo and Jim actually wrote the work. But then he just Jim decided he wanted to go off on his own. And Columbo does say a good line that he says, I'd love to be a writer. That's a terrific talent. And I thought, thank you very much, Columbo.
[00:34:26] Oh, thanks, Columbo. Stop it. And then just before all the stuff with the woman Lily happens, the dead body is found on Ken's lawn. And Ken makes this whole big thing, which I think kind of proves, like you said before, about him being too cocky, is he's almost, it kind of becomes of, I think becomes obvious
[00:34:52] to Columbo at this point that Ken is the most obvious suspect. He just needs to like find some hard evidence because he makes up this whole story about like he's got a letter with a bunch of names and that Jim was writing a book about sort of underground gangs and all these people. And he had loads of people after him because he was going to do an expose book on like mafia gangs.
[00:35:21] And it just gets all a bit like ridiculous. And then Ken finds Jim's body on his lawn and says that he called Columbo immediately. But like you've mentioned, and like Columbo sees, his post has been opened and Columbo finds it very strange that he had time to open the letters. And the way he says it, he goes, isn't it funny how people are different?
[00:35:47] If it were me and I found my partner dead, I'd never think to open my mail. It's so good because yeah, the, yeah, the, the, the, the affability or the, isn't it funny? Like I just like the, the unassuming way he delivers it is so much more cutting. It's so good. And I think it's this point because Ken has been really like chummy to Columbo up to this point.
[00:36:14] And I think it's because he thought that he was a bit dumb and that he could basically feed Columbo all these lies and get away with it. And then I think at this point he sees that Columbo is more switched on than he assumed. Because from this point he gets really pissed off every time Columbo appears. Yeah. Yeah. That is definitely the switching moment.
[00:36:37] And it's, it's so good because initially, especially I imagine if you were watching it for the first time back then, you'd be like, oh, he is not this stupid. Surely he's not this stupid. What is going on? Who put him in charge? Blah, blah, blah. Blah. So you're, you are kind of waiting for that. Yeah. That moment because you're like, surely not. But it's still so satisfying. Yeah, definitely. When he does do it.
[00:37:05] And the way, yeah. And the, the, the way these kind of bleed through slowly before the reveal at the end where he is just full professional. Yeah. His tone changes, doesn't it? Oh, but it's, it's great. It's so good. Yeah. Yeah. Really good. And yeah. So then we have all the stuff that we've kind of covered about Lily and then the second body, which is hers. Yes. And actually, yes.
[00:37:32] Do you know what the silent, you saying about how the way she's killed and then the disposal of her body isn't very cozy. I think you are right with that because she does this like silent scream, which is again, very horror film, but like, like I really, it's like a soap horror film. It's like so overacted, but in a. It's yeah, it's very schlocky. It's like hammer house of horror kind of. Yeah.
[00:38:00] It's because it's POV of the killer as well. It's so 70s schlock. It's great. Yeah. It's the thing is at the time, I wonder if that would have been scarier. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe. But, but now it's just very, it's like almost camp. I did. I laughed. Yeah. I did. Yeah. I laughed. Yeah. It is camp. I think that's the thing with, I mean, I think that's the thing with cozy crimes that I love is there's a campness to a lot of them.
[00:38:30] Definitely. I think it's just interesting that I think for potentially the first time, and it's probably because of how long ago it came out, we are seeing unintentional camp cozy crime. Yeah. That's true. Rather than very intentional camp. Yeah. In that instance. But yeah, the silent scream just absolutely got me so I'm still chuckling, still chuckling when he's disposing of the body, which is a really weird headspace to be in. Yeah, definitely.
[00:38:58] And then Columbo just appears at the second home, which was so funny to me because he was just like at the window the next day, which really shocked Ken. That really made me laugh. Yeah. Columbo basically goes back to see the dead man's wife, Joanna, and she doesn't really want to admit to herself that Ken could be the killer, which I think is fair enough. They've known him for years. Yeah. But he says at this point that he knows who did it, but it's all circumstantial and now
[00:39:26] he needs some hard evidence, which made me think about how we've spoken about this quite a lot with cozy crimes of there's quite a few times in older ones where you're like, would people actually be able to like get charged off of the so-called evidence they have? And then in newer cozy crimes, it becomes like in Death Valley, it's become a bit of a trope of Janie being like, well, John Chappell might not, he might have figured it out, but
[00:39:56] I'll actually go out and get the evidence. Exactly. And at least here Columbo realizes he needs the evidence. Yes. He, I think it's, it subverts the cozy crime trope of needing a partner. I don't want Columbo to have a partner. He doesn't need one. No. He needs to work by himself. He needs to shine by himself and he does, he has the duality enough for two people, I think. Yeah. It's great.
[00:40:26] I think looking it up and from the episodes I've seen, he, he doesn't, it's always just him. Um, at one point I believe he gets a dog called dog and dog. Okay. I'm okay with that. Yeah. Dog accompanies him, but obviously it's still him solving it. And, um, also as well, I had heard about this, but you'll notice in this episode and apparently like constantly throughout the whole series, uh, Columbo mentions a lot
[00:40:53] about his wife and we hear a lot about his wife, which is very sweet. Yeah. He's obviously a wife guy, which is nice. Um, but there was a spinoff called Mrs. Columbo. Yes, there is. I had heard about, um, it's only two series long. Apparently it didn't like do that well. And I think apparently after the first series, they actually called it something different and took out any references to Columbo because I think they thought that might have been the reason it wasn't doing very well.
[00:41:23] But I think it's cards was marked from the beginning probably. Yeah. I wouldn't. I mean, we'll probably end up covering it. We will save any hot takes. Yeah. Yeah. As a concept, not solved. No, no, definitely not. Um, so, oh, and then at this point we come to the courtier, the reveal, uh, Columbo, basically,
[00:41:52] um, Ken comes up to the office that it all happened in and Columbo's in there with his head in his hands, reading the last of their books because Ken had given Columbo loads of the books to help him solve the crime. Um, and it's just so funny because Ken's like, what the hell are you doing in here? And he was like, we've got something to talk about. I've come here to arrest you.
[00:42:15] Yeah, it's great. It should be clunky, but from him it really works. It works, yeah. Because it's, it's the, yeah, the casualness and that, because we've still not quite switched it. Yeah. Yeah. Because he's still doing this slightly bumbling thing and that's why Ken laughs it off. Yeah. Like thinks it's ridiculous and that's why it's even more of a, yeah, that's why it's even more of a gut punch when it's like, yeah, I've, I've got you.
[00:42:45] Yeah. And he does actually say, I've really got you. Yeah, I know. It's great. It's so satisfying. Yeah. And he really takes that, that, yeah, that not quite bumbling, but that like underestimated energy right until he, he punches him with the, mate, you're cooked. Yeah. You are cooked. And here is exactly why.
[00:43:11] It was brilliant. He had some, so many good lines. He said that, um, uh, he said something about, how, um, he's figured it out, uh, and he like worked it out. Not with, he goes, not with the witness because you killed the witness and his timing was like brilliant comic timing. It's great. It really is. It really is. Yeah. Very satisfying.
[00:43:34] He also was like, oh, the first murder was done really well. And the second murder was done really badly. Uh, because Jim had come up with the first murder. You came up with the second murder and he was like, you've got no talent for murder. And all his burns were so good. So good. And I think, yeah, with, if he hadn't been so arrogant, it's like, Columbus just meeting him where he's at. Oh yeah, yeah, definitely.
[00:44:03] Which is because like, he's not being unnecessarily harsh. Everything he is saying has been completely earned by this guy. Yeah, definitely. And yeah, it is, it's such an effective takedown. Yeah. In every sense of the word. It's so satisfying. Oh yeah. I was going to ask, were you satisfied by the ending and with it? I definitely was. Yeah. As I was enjoying the, the switch up of the format in terms of the mystery
[00:44:33] very much. And, but for a while you, I mean, that's, that's the nature of suspense versus, um, you know, um, like the mystery aspect of it is we do know where it's going. Yeah. Yeah. But we want to see how it gets to the end rather than not knowing. And so, yeah, so it's, you're expecting something very different and that means that the ending has to be satisfying. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:45:01] I think you can get away with a slightly less satisfying twist in a mystery of, we don't know who did it. Yeah. Yeah. You have to be able to pull off an ending when you introduce the, the murderer right from the beginning. And I think it absolutely did that. Yeah. That's such a good point because there's, you know, cozy crime shows that you kind of think, oh, okay. Yeah. That was the murderer. And then later on you're like,
[00:45:26] what's happening about? And there's like a few potholes and stuff. Um, but, uh, yeah, with this, it was like you said, because we know it has to be satisfying in a different way, which kind of gives them a different, um, challenge, I guess, as a writer. Yeah. Yeah. I will definitely be watching more. Brilliant. But I will still allow you to plead your case.
[00:45:53] Yes. So I will plead my case. I think that while you're right, that maybe some tonally, some of the things aren't quite as cozy crime as, as other things. I do think it's still within the spectrum of a cozy crime, mainly because of Columbo. I think he is a great, uh, under, uh, maybe not underappreciated and definitely not in the real world, but in the
[00:46:20] world of the show, he's kind of an overlooked, um, uh, detective. And I think that's a bit of a, it's a good trope that we've come to know and love in, in a lot of cozy crimes. And I think that while, yes, the second murder was a bit horror, like hammer house of horror, it still is within the spectrum of a cozy crime because I don't think it ever is like too, uh, graphic. It's not too gory.
[00:46:51] It's dark, but not like super dark. I think it still is within that, uh, cozy crime sort of framework. And I just think that it would be good if more people in the UK watched Columbo because I think he's a great, um, character. I completely agree with all of it. And I would say that maybe with the passage of time, yeah, 70s dark has become 2020s unintentional camp, which can add to the
[00:47:20] coziness. So yeah, completely on, completely on board. And I want Columbo to hold my hand through many a mystery. Yes, definitely. Definitely. He is a sweet, a sweet character. And also apparently one of his daughters, like the guy in real life, his daughters actually became a private investigator, which is pretty cool. Love that. Love that. Life imitating art. Exactly. That's amazing.
[00:47:48] Ah, brilliant. Perfect. Well, thank you so much for watching Columbo, Becca. And I'm very pleased you liked him and it. Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to watch Columbo for the first time. I now understand what Mark is talking about in Peach. I get it. Fully on board. Perfect. And if anyone wants to follow us online, um, our Instagram handle is at cozy.crime time.
[00:48:18] We're on TikTok and YouTube at cozycrime time. All one word for those two. Yeah, that's right. And we do want to hear from you guys. Yes. We've admitted for the first time that neither of us are an expert on this one. No one present is an expert. So if you're a massive Columbo fan, tell us the best episodes, tell us the ones we should be watching, the ones we should be avoiding.
[00:48:41] Is it a cozy crime? If you've seen more, maybe it, maybe it gets less cozy over time. And if you've got time while you're telling us that maybe leave us a review as well. Brilliant. Thank you so much. Thanks so much, Jade. And until next time, stay cozy. Don't commit crimes. This podcast is part of Podomity, the UK's podcast comedy network. Why not laugh at what else we've got?
[00:49:10] Visit Podomity.com.



